Which Green Bay Packers Quarterback Is Better?

One is a sure fire Hall of Famer who was the face of the franchise for years before an ugly split. The other has said all the right things and emerged from the shadows to become one of, if not the best in the game right now. Both lay claim to some truly gaudy numbers, both have won the ultimate game and both will forever be remembered in Green Bay lore. But which player is truly the best?

Brett Favre
Aaron Rodgers
You must be logged in to vote and add comments. Login or Create an account.
juice16811/23/2011It's too early to tell for sure, but Rodgers is certainly making a case for being the greatest Green BAy quarterback of all time.

Favre was great and is a sure fire Hall of Famer, but one can't lose sight of the fact that along with winning many games for the Packers that they wouldn't have won without him, he also lost the team a number of games through careless play and overblown confidence (not to mention some pretty important games for the Jets and Vikings).

Thus far, Rodgers is putting up MVP numbers and winning games while playing within the system and not making the types of mistakes that lose games.